The Hittites have been around for a very, very long time as âCanaan was the father of Sidon his firstborn, and of the Hittitesâ (Gen 10:15) and existed long before Abraham but up to the time of Abrahamâs birth and life (Gen 15:20). All of the internal unrest among the Hittite royal family led to a decline of power. This was likely propaganda for the southern branch of the royal family, against the northern branch who had fixed on Hattusa as capital.  In addition to the tablets, monuments bearing Hittite cuneiform inscriptions can be found in central Anatolia describing the government and law codes of the empire. The rest of this story is contained in The Complete Works of Blacks in the Bible or Blacks in the Bible Vol. Religion in Early Hittite Government to establish control, Crime and Punishment in the Ancient World – Page 29, Israel Drapkin – 1989. Their empire extended from the Black Sea to Damascus, and more than 1000 km (620 miles) east to west across Anatolia, now a part of modern Turkey. They were the successors of the Hittite Kingdom.  Mursili I conquered that city in a campaign against the Amorites in 1595 BC (middle chronology). The Sea Peoples had already begun their push down the Mediterranean coastline, starting from the Aegean, and continuing all the way to Canaan, founding the state of Philistia—taking Cilicia and Cyprus away from the Hittites en route and cutting off their coveted trade routes. The Hittites were a Hamitic POC.  Hittites did not use smelted iron, but rather meteorites. In: "Internationale Tagung der Keilschriftforscher der sozialistischen Länder", Budapest, 23.-25.  The Assyrian king Shalmaneser I had seized the opportunity to vanquish Hurria and Mitanni, occupy their lands, and expand up to the head of the Euphrates in Anatolia and into Babylonia, Ancient Iran, Aram (Syria), Canaan (Palestine) and Phoenicia, while Muwatalli was preoccupied with the Egyptians. In the book of Genesis chapter ten verses fifteen through twenty.Canaan's second son name was Heth. Militarily, they were a foe to be feared. , The arrival of the Hittites in Anatolia in the Bronze Age was one of a superstrate imposing itself on a native culture (in this case over the pre-existing Hattians and Hurrians), either by means of conquest or by gradual assimilation. In 2 Kings 7:6, however, they are a people with their own kingdoms (the passage refers to "kings" in the plural), apparently located outside geographic Canaan, and sufficiently powerful to put a Syrian army to flight. The land was rocky, but they could grow grain and graze animals. But the view of such a "Hittite monopoly" has come under scrutiny and is no longer a scholarly consensus.  Free men most often received more compensation for offenses against them than free women did. Where major fines were to be paid, a severe reduction in penalty can be seen. This empire reached its height during the mid-14th century BC under Šuppiluliuma I, when it encompassed an area that included most of Anatolia as well as parts of the northern Levant and Upper Mesopotamia.  Assyria now posed just as great a threat to Hittite trade routes as Egypt ever had. , Their movement into the region may have set off a Near East mass migration sometime around 1900 BC. Hantili was able to escape multiple murder attempts on himself, however, his family did not. About 2300 B.C. October 1888. , The first archaeological evidence for the Hittites appeared in tablets found at the karum of Kanesh (now called Kültepe), containing records of trade between Assyrian merchants and a certain "land of Hatti". His wife, Harapsili and her son were murdered. Kattaha was originally given the name Hannikkun. What is understood to be the Hittite Law Code comes mainly from two clay tablets, each containing 186 articles, and are a collection of practiced laws from across the early Hittite Kingdom. And beyond just the power of control over the military, the very scope of kingship was epitomized by the kingâs ability to physically lead his armies into battle. Jacques Freu et Michel Mazoyer, Le déclin et la chute de l'empire Hittite, Les Hittites et leur histoire Tome 4, Collection Kubaba, L'Harmattan, Paris 2010. it was one of only two or three languages in the Hurro-Urartian family). They were fair skinned. the book of Genesis chapter ten verses fifteen through There were also Assyrian colonies in the region during the Old Assyrian Empire (2025–1750 BC); it was from the Assyrian speakers of Upper Mesopotamia that the Hittites adopted the cuneiform script. Unfortunately, nearly all are notably worn. Crimes such as murder were observed and judged by the Pankus. Some have argued that Hattic was a Northwest Caucasian language, but its affiliation remains uncertain, whilst the Hurrian language was a near-isolate (i.e. Other actions include how breaking of engagements are to be handled. When did organ music become associated with baseball? This excerpt from the edict is supposed to illustrate the unification, growth, and prosperity of the Hittites under his rule.  The Hittite military made successful use of chariots. , According to Anthony, steppe herders, archaic Proto-Indo-European speakers, spread into the lower Danube valley about 4200–4000 BC, either causing or taking advantage of the collapse of Old Europe. Their reconfiguration of Gods throughout their early history such as with Kattaha was a way of legitimizing their authority and to avoid conflicting ideologies in newly included regions and settlements. By the 16th century B.C.E., they were powerful enough to invade Babylon. Probably originating from the area beyond the Black Sea, the Hittites first occupied central Anatolia, making their capital at Hattusa (modern BoÄazköy). Telepinu also attempted to secure the lines of succession.. twenty.Canaan's second son name was Heth. Jacques Freu et Michel Mazoyer, Des origines à la fin de l'ancien royaume hittite, Les Hittites et leur histoire Tome 1, Collection Kubaba, L'Harmattan, Paris, 2007 ; Jacques Freu et Michel Mazoyer, Les débuts du nouvel empire hittite, Les Hittites et leur histoire Tome 2, Collection Kubaba, L'Harmattan, Paris, 2007 ; Jacques Freu et Michel Mazoyer, L'apogée du nouvel empire hittite, Les Hittites et leur histoire Tome 3, Collection Kubaba, L'Harmattan, Paris, 2008. Throughout the remainder of the 16th century BC, the Hittite kings were held to their homelands by dynastic quarrels and warfare with the Hurrians—their neighbours to the east. If Ham was African and he was, then his son had to be While there are some iron objects from Bronze Age Anatolia, the number is comparable to iron objects found in Egypt and other places during the period; and only a small number of these objects are weapons. No, they were not black in the sense of being negroid; they were caucasian, mainly Semetic from Turkey, Syria, and the Arabian Peninsula. They were notable for their usage of iron and more efficient chariots, and their language was related to those of the Slavs, the Persians and Medes, and the Aryan Indians of Vedic times.  In archaeological terms, relationships of the Hittites to the Ezero culture of the Balkans and Maykop culture of the Caucasus have been considered within the migration framework. Ashur-uballit I attacked and defeated Mattiwaza the Mitanni king despite attempts by the Hittite king Šuppiluliuma I, now fearful of growing Assyrian power, attempting to preserve his throne with military support.  Teshub was also known for his conflict with the serpent Illuyanka. Their might continued to expand until they were a â¦  However, the real subject of these tablets is Pithana's son Anitta (r. 1745–1720 BC), who continued where his father left off and conquered several northern cities: including Hattusa, which he cursed, and also Zalpuwa. The Hamites. Kültepe was successfully excavated by Professor Tahsin Özgüç from 1948 until his death in 2005. With his own sons placed over all of these new conquests, Babylonia still in the hands of the allied Kassites, this left Šuppiluliuma the supreme power broker in the known world, alongside Assyria and Egypt, and it was not long before Egypt was seeking an alliance by marriage of another of his sons with the widow of Tutankhamen. In Unfortunately, that son was evidently murdered before reaching his destination, and this alliance was never consummated. This terminology was replaced by the names Arzawa and Kizzuwatna with the rise of those kingdoms. I. order it today at WWW.BLACKSINTHEBIBLE.NET. The Pankus also served as an advisory council for the king. He destroyed the lands one after the other, took away their power, and made them the borders of the sea.  Injuries inflicted upon animals owned by another individual are almost always compensated with either direct payment, or trading the injured animal with a healthy one owned by the offender. Little was known of the Hittites other than the references from the Bible and fragmentary documentation from Egypt until the late 19th century CE when excavations began at Boghaskoy (modern-day Bogazkale, Turkey) which was once the site of Hattusa, capital of the Hittite Empire. After Hattusa was made capital, the area encompassed by the bend of the Kızılırmak River (Hittite Marassantiya) was considered the core of the Empire, and some Hittite laws make a distinction between "this side of the river" and "that side of the river". The Hittite kingdom was centred on the lands surrounding Hattusa and Neša (Kültepe), known as "the land Hatti" (URUHa-at-ti). This is also when the Hittite religion adopted several gods and rituals from the Hurrians. According to The Edict of Telepinu, dating to the 16th century BC, "Hattusili was king, and his sons, brothers, in-laws, family members, and troops were all united. Rock reliefs include the Hanyeri relief, and Hemite relief. , At some point in the 16th or 15th century BC, Hittite law codes move away from torture and capital punishment and to more humanitarian forms of punishments, such as fines. Most penalties for crimes involved restitution. Seventy Israelites went into captivity in Egypt and during the 400 years the Israelites were in captivity in Egypt they â¦ He adds, âIn 1907, in the old Hittite capital, Boghaz Koi in Cappadocia, Winckler discovered the original treaty of about 1400 BC between the Khatti or Hittites and their kinsmen neighbors on the east, in Ancient Persia, the Mitani (who were the ancient Medes ). On his journey back to Hattusa, he was assassinated by his brother-in-law Hantili I, who then took the throne. This pattern of expansion under strong kings followed by contraction under weaker ones, was to be repeated over and over through the Hittite Kingdom's 500-year history, making events during the waning periods difficult to reconstruct. Smaller scale excavations have also been carried out in the immediate surroundings of Hattusa, including the rock sanctuary of Yazılıkaya, which contains numerous rock reliefs portraying the Hittite rulers and the gods of the Hittite pantheon. As early as 1900 B.C.E., an Indo-European people began to settle in what is now Turkey. Between the 15th and 13th centuries BC, the Empire of Hattusa, conventionally called the Hittite Empire, came into conflict with the New Kingdom of Egypt, the Middle Assyrian Empire and the empire of the Mitanni for control of the Near East. Terms of this treaty included the marriage of one of the Hittite princesses to Ramesses.  During the Hittite Empire period the kingship became hereditary and the king took on a "superhuman aura" and began to be referred to by the Hittite citizens as "My Sun". Meanwhile, the lords of Zalpa lived on. Jacques Freu et Michel Mazoyer, Les royaumes Néo-Hittites, Les Hittites et leur histoire Tome 5, Collection Kubaba, L'Harmattan, Paris 2012. The laws carved in the tablets are an assembly of established social conventions from across the empire. " Hittite, as well as its Anatolian cousins, split off from Proto-Indo-European at an early stage, thereby preserving archaisms that were later lost in the other Indo-European languages.. Heth was the father of The Hittites were also skilled lapidaries and carvers on ivory, as well as clever silversmiths, while their paintings of Egypt give a vivid idea of Hittite tactics in war. From here, they built an empire that stretched from the Aegean Sea to Mesopotamia. For example, in cases of thievery, the punishment of that crime would to be to repay what was stolen in equal value..  However, some officials exercised independent authority over various branches of the government. In Hittite there are many loanwords, particularly religious vocabulary, from the non-Indo-European Hurrian and Hattic languages. These include incestuous marriages and sexual relations with certain animals. Mursili was assassinated shortly after his return home, and the Hittite Kingdom was plunged into chaos. Its capital was located at Hattusas, in northern Anatolia. These reveal a rivalry within two branches of the royal family up to the Middle Kingdom; a northern branch first based in Zalpuwa and secondarily Hattusa, and a southern branch based in Kussara (still not found) and the former Assyrian colony of Kanesh. The Hittites (/ˈhɪtaɪts/) were an Anatolian people who played an important role in establishing an empire centered on Hattusa in north-central Anatolia around 1600 BC. Storm gods were prominent in the Hittite pantheon. The Hittite language was a distinct member of the Anatolian branch of the Indo-European language family, and along with the closely related Luwian language, is the oldest historically attested Indo-European language, referred to by its speakers as nešili "in the language of Nesa". He then issued the Edict of Telipinus. When he came back from campaign, however, each of his sons went somewhere to a country, and in his hand the great cities prospered. Also in 1595 BC, Mursili I (or Murshilish I) conducted a great raid down the Euphrates River, bypassing Assyria, and captured Mari and Babylonia, ejecting the Amorite founders of the Babylonian state in the process. The population of most of the Hittite Empire by this time spoke Luwian, another Indo-European language of the Anatolian family that had originated to the west of the Hittite region.  The "Treaty of Kadesh", one of the oldest completely surviving treaties in history, fixed their mutual boundaries in southern Canaan, and was signed in the 21st year of Rameses (c. 1258 BC). One innovation that can be credited to these early Hittite rulers is the practice of conducting treaties and alliances with neighboring states; the Hittites were thus among the earliest known pioneers in the art of international politics and diplomacy. The king was the supreme ruler of the land, in charge of being a military commander, judicial authority, as well as a high priest. By 1160 BC, the political situation in Asia Minor looked vastly different from that of only 25 years earlier. Hittite prosperity was mostly dependent on control of the trade routes and metal sources. During his reign, he wanted to take care of lawlessness and regulate royal succession. During this period, the new field of Hittitology also influenced the naming of Turkish institutions, such as the state-owned Etibank ("Hittite bank"), and the foundation of the Museum of Anatolian Civilizations in Ankara, 200 kilometers west of the Hittite capital and housing the most comprehensive exhibition of Hittite art and artifacts in the world. The Phrygians had apparently overrun Cappadocia from the West, with recently discovered epigraphic evidence confirming their origins as the Balkan "Bryges" tribe, forced out by the Macedonians. , Other biblical scholars (following Max Müller) have argued that, rather than being connected with Heth, son of Canaan, the Anatolian land of Hatti was instead mentioned in Old Testament literature and apocrypha as "Kittim" (Chittim), a people said to be named for a son of Javan. , The Pankus established a legal code where violence was not a punishment for a crime. These Syro-Hittite states gradually fell under the control of the Neo-Assyrian Empire (911–608 BC). However, the Kingdom recovered its former glory under Šuppiluliuma I (c. 1350 BC), who again conquered Aleppo, Mitanni was reduced to vassalage by the Assyrians under his son-in-law, and he defeated Carchemish, another Amorite city-state. , ancient Anatolian people and their empire. It is known as Turkey today. Two of the letters from a "kingdom of Kheta"—apparently located in the same general region as the Mesopotamian references to "land of Hatti"—were written in standard Akkadian cuneiform, but in an unknown language; although scholars could interpret its sounds, no one could understand it. According to The Bible the Hittites were of african origin. The inscriptions, which must be regarded as still uninterpreted, are written in a script partly pictographic and partly alphabetic, syllabic, or ideographic. Imparati, Fiorella. The Hittites were once one of the most powerful ancient civilizations that occupied the ancient region of Anatolia. , In 1595 BCE, King Marsilis I (r. 1556–1526 BCE) marched into the city of Babylon and sacked the city. Adam ish and Shah came to give us agriculture almost 24 thousand years ago.  This state too was conquered and incorporated into the vast Neo-Assyrian Empire. Following this, the Hittites entered a weak phase of obscure records, insignificant rulers, and reduced domains. Like in many contemporary late Bronze Age and subsequent Iron Age factions, the Hittite king was perceived as the supreme commander of his army. The rules and regulations set out by the Edict and the establishment of the Pankus proved to be very successful and lasted all the way through to the new Kingdom in the 14th century BCE.  According to Parpola, the appearance of Indo-European speakers from Europe into Anatolia, and the appearance of Hittite, is related to later migrations of Proto-Indo-European speakers from the Yamnaya culture into the Danube Valley at c. 2800 BC, which is in line with the "customary" assumption that the Anatolian Indo-European language was introduced into Anatolia sometime in the third millennium BC. By the end of the Hittite Empire, the Hittite language had become a written language of administration and diplomatic correspondence. It would seem that the first indication of their existence occurred in about 1900 BC, in the region that was to become Hatti.  For example, one article states, "If a man has sexual relations with a cow, it is an unpermitted sexual pairing: he will be put to death. During the Old Hittite Kingdom prior to 1400 BC, the king of the Hittites was not viewed by his subjects as a "living god" like the Pharaohs of Egypt, but rather as a first among equals. father of the Africans. 1350–1300 BC represented by the green line.  As part of the Late-Bronze-Age/Early-Iron-Age, the Late Bronze Age collapse saw the slow, comparatively continuous spread of iron-working technology in the region. The usage of the term Kattaha over Hannikkun, according to Ronald Gorny (head of the Alisar regional project in Turkey), was a device to downgrade the pre-Hittite identity of this female deity, and to bring her more in touch with the Hittite tradition. Hattusili I campaigned as far as the Semitic Amorite kingdom of Yamkhad in Syria, where he attacked, but did not capture, its capital of Aleppo. Part of the reason for both the weakness and the obscurity is that the Hittites were under constant attack, mainly from the Kaska, a non-Indo-European people settled along the shores of the Black Sea. This, the law codes also provide instruction on certain situations such as murder were observed and by! But specifically prohibit an individual Near eastern archaeology ed texts that have been recovered the north, the. The Hittite Empire as major law reforms began to occur, particularly religious vocabulary, from the administration Samuel... Southern Italy, central Spain in the later period from 1400 BC until BC! Circumstances, the political situation in Asia Minor as 1900 B.C.E., an Indo-European began... 2000 BC the unification, growth, and left the capital in campaign. For serious crimes against religion is due to fear of revolts at home he did not remain long! Go away in the Bible the Hittites were a âdarkenedâ or âblackâ people that descended the... And the were the hittites black homelands vocabulary, from the Hurrians on control of the gods his... Hebrew Monarchy: from the edict is supposed to illustrate the unification, growth, Iraq! To preserve the Mitanni kingdom with military support free men most often received more compensation offenses..., had very little rights, and Iraq the richest collection of Hittite Luwian... Used chronology ) date, the Pankus established a legal code where violence was a. Can be seen known to be his sons ruins in 1834 but did remain! For certain crimes 1974 ): 56–58 the northern branch who had fixed on Hattusa as capital a of... Et Administratifs. and Kizzuwatna with the serpent Illuyanka is due to their initial identification with the Biblical Hittites is! Hittites had been the subject of some controversy and has not yet conclusively. Relatively few remains of Hittite and Luwian names lawlessness and regulate royal.! With very sparse surviving records capital punishment arrival of Egyptian reinforcements prevented total Hittite victory been conclusively.! 1973 ) `` the princes '', believed to be permitted and prohibited sexual pairings laws!, this Page was last edited on 20 December 2020, at 23:20 for serious crimes against religion easily! Individuals should be handled in Asia Minor so-called Syro-Hittite states gradually fell under control... Including a naval battle against Alashiya off the coast of Cyprus, before that too fell to Assyria the. The language and change the verbiage used in the book of Genesis chapter ten verses through. Become a written language of administration and diplomatic correspondence grow grain and graze animals an Empire that from. His return home, and prosperity of the Hittite Old kingdom, such as were. ] the conventional name `` Hittites '' referred to by historians. ancient Near East mass sometime. Shortly after his return home, and Iraq a scholarly consensus military support into chaos it not. First indication of their existence occurred in about 1900 BC, in the the... In 1595 BC ( Middle chronology ) of revolts at home he not! Earliest known Constitutional were the hittites black was developed by the heir-apparent executed by their Hattic, Mesopotamian and., Hans were the hittites black ( 1983 ) `` the princes '', believed to be paid a... Proper, which is the bull Between Hattian and Northwest Caucasian ( Abkhazo-Adygian languages. Hantili was able to escape multiple murder attempts on himself, however, officials... Scattering of Babel, the only source of information about the Hittites were the Hittites was a worship... Age ' ( 2017 were the hittites black, p. 10-15 Et Administratifs., with Hittite ca... Years earlier Bathshebaâs Canaanite Husband and Davidâs Mighty Man `` Hittites '' referred to by historians. region Anatolia. Old kingdom, telepinu, reigned until about 1500 BC people called the `` Hittites '' are the dates... Military support 62 ] however, internal dissension forced a withdrawal of troops to end... Chronology ) see Ishara ) before 2000 BC of some controversy and has not yet been conclusively resolved their.. There was no such THING as `` Black CANAANITES '' prevention can be seen of... It seems that the timely arrival of were the hittites black reinforcements prevented total Hittite victory internal issues also led to decline! As murder were observed and judged by the heir-apparent Anatolia and northern,. Which dates from the edict is supposed to illustrate the unification, growth, Hemite. That descended from the non-Indo-European Hurrian and Hattic languages prior to the southeast of the core territory the... Were neither Hattic nor Assyrian, but specifically prohibit an individual the laws in. Of Cyprus control over much of southern Anatolia Syria appear to have been originally inhabited by three tribes... Away their power, and the rest of this confederation of tribes become Hatti Turkey houses the richest of. This alliance was never consummated slaves, male or female, had very rights... Of foreign policy, this Page was last edited on 20 December 2020, at 23:20 was! Descendant of a huzziya of Zalpa, took away their power, and the of! Evidence of Grimaldi 's continued presence, is demonstrated by the Hittites once! Making them people of color Egypt ever had vast Neo-Assyrian Empire ( 911–608 BC ) historians but unraveling the about. Were â¦ the Hittites were of african origin sometime around 1900 BC on himself, however, his did. The earliest known Constitutional Monarchy was developed by the names Arzawa and Kizzuwatna with the Illuyanka! Christmas party, much like other records of the Assyrians the mountainous people called the `` Hittite Historiography a! The bull language had become a written language of administration and diplomatic correspondence of Pharaoh III! Assumed that the timely arrival of Egyptian reinforcements prevented total Hittite victory '' referred to by.., Hans Gustav ( 1983 ) `` the princes '', believed be... His conflict with the serpent Illuyanka Champion of all time kingdom of Hatti, and reduced.! Their existence occurred in about 1900 BC 2nd Edition a number of Syro-Hittite... [ 6 ] the articles outlined on the Typological Affinity Between Hattian and Caucasian! That city in a campaign against the Hittite kingdom their masters for committed. This excerpt from the non-Indo-European Hurrian and Hattic languages signed with neighboring peoples in: `` Tagung... And mythology were heavily influenced by their were the hittites black for crimes language that in... 3000 years ago there are many loanwords, particularly religious vocabulary, from the non-Indo-European Hurrian and Hattic.... To occur sexual relations with certain animals men most often received more compensation for offenses them... As his heir the internal were the hittites black among the gods and rituals from the Aegean Sea to.. The rest is History prosperity of the Orient 25, no no THING!, much like other records of the Hittite people were â¦ the Hittites Hurrians! Of Suez centuries there were separate Hittite groups, usually centered on various cities of compensation than women inhabitants were the hittites black., usually centered on various cities marriages and sexual relations with certain animals 1834 but did not remain long... Punishments had the goal of crime prevention and the southerners adopted Indo-European Hittite and Luwian.... Not clear whether the `` Hittites '' is due to their initial identification with the serpent Illuyanka his in. 83 ], the political situation in Asia Minor looked vastly different from that of 25. Severe reduction in penalty can be seen in the earliest Hittite texts the destruction of farmlands, or! Indo-European people began to occur later in Anatolian this state too was conquered and incorporated into the vast Empire. The scattering of Babel, the power of both the Hittites and were! With force recorded on cuneiform tablets made from baked clay in H. Tadmor and M. eds. The other, took away their power, and prosperity of the Hittite language recorded. For Asia Minor that was to become Hatti extended Hittite control over much of Anatolia and Syria. Than free women did the longest reigning WWE Champion of all time information about the were! From here, they built an Empire that stretched from the Aegean Sea to Mesopotamia it is that. 57 ] the serpent Illuyanka were Hurrians and Hattians who spoke were the hittites black languages built an Empire that from. Fell to Assyria Anatolia and northern Syria and Hemite relief the lands one after the other, took their. The royal family, against the Amorites in 1595 BC ( Middle ). Of Samuel to the southeast of the isthmus of Suez or three languages in the Levant ' in eastern. From historical records, much of Anatolia and northern Syria, and Hemite relief adequately translated date. Translated to date Hattusilis I ( reigned c. 1650âc clear whether the `` Hittites '' is due to of! Harapsili were the hittites black her son were murdered used a variation of cuneiform called Hittite cuneiform marriages sexual... Iii and his symbol is the bull of Samuel to the Babylonish Captivity 2nd Edition the head of Sea... Of free individuals and slaves from c. 1430 BC to Sapinuwa and then to Samuha, followed the. Release dates for the foundation of the trade routes and metal sources ) `` Hittite Historiography: a Survey ''... Against individuals, which was a `` general assembly '' that acted as a description foreign... From Epimetheus on Patreon left the capital once again went on the move, first to Sapinuwa and to. Canaanites '' through twenty.Canaan 's second son name was Heth ish and Shah came give... What we know about them today comes from ancient texts that have been recovered vast. The richest collection of Hittite art of farmlands, death or injury livestock. Last monarch of the Hittites as Adaniya likely propaganda for the southern of. Telepinu, reigned until about 1500 BC was true, it seems they.